Skip to content
World clockEU--:--UK--:--USA--:--CN--:--PLDEFRIT中文EN

portal about AI and technologyevents · analysis · interviews · technical background

Search
LIVE
›

Samal assessor questioned over land records in Sara Duterte impeachment trial

The impeachment court questioned Samal assessor Enumerables on 10 November about land records for a property linked to Vice President Sara Duterte's husband, on the second day of her defense case in a trial that could bar her from office.

WorldExplainerDr. Amara PatelPublished: 10 November 20264 min readSources 14
Samal assessor questioned over land records in Sara Duterte impeachment trial

Presiding Officer Francis Escudero asked John Kenneth Enumerables, the city assessor of the Island Garden City of Samal, why Duterte's SALN listed Barangay Matanos while the assessor's documents identified Barangay San Isidro, Inquirer reported. Enumerables first said both entries referred to the same property based on market and assessed value, then said no Barangay Matanos exists in the Island Garden City of Samal.

Senator-judge Panfilo Lacson called out confusing land records, and Senator-judge Erwin Tulfo reprimanded Enumerables for not coordinating with the Registry of Deeds and the Land Registration Authority, according to Inquirer. Escudero also directed the impeachment clerk of court to follow up with the previous day's witness, Davao City assessor Jaime Adalin, for a list of properties owned by Duterte and Carpio.

Defense opening

The defense opened on 9 November after the Senate paused the trial for three weeks to focus on national budget deliberations, Davao Today reported. Its first witness, Davao City assessor Jaime Adalin, presented tax declarations and assessment records that the defense said showed a property linked to Duterte had been disclosed in her 2024 SALN, AsiaOne reported. The Samal lot is allegedly owned by her husband, lawyer Manases Carpio. Philstar reported that the acting Samal register of deeds testified Carpio bought it for P3.4 million in 2018; Davao Today reported records showing P3.45 million. Prosecutors say the property was not reflected in Duterte's 2019 SALN.

Article II

Article II, the only remaining impeachment charge, accuses Duterte of amassing unexplained wealth and failing to truthfully disclose properties and corporate shareholdings, including assets attributed to her husband, Davao Today reported. Prosecutors withdrew three other articles covering confidential funds, bribery and threats. Davao Today identified the financial analyst as Alexander Cabrera and reported his estimate of about P817.87 million in alleged unexplained wealth and undeclared assets from 2022 to 2025. AsiaOne reported that a forensic financial analyst estimated more than 800 million pesos in unexplained assets, including remittances from entities in China and Hong Kong. The defense disputes the findings and has questioned the admissibility of several documents.

Escudero noted Duterte's annual salary is P4.2 million and her net worth rose from P71 million in 2022 to P98 million in 2025, Davao Today reported. Cabrera's estimate is more than eight times her declared net worth in 2025.

Davao Today reported that SEC director Gerardo del Rosario testified Duterte was a shareholder and board member of Metro City Chow Foods Corp. from 2018 to 2025. Records from 2022 to 2024 show she paid P50,000 in subscription fees for a 20% stake, and prosecutors argued this breached a constitutional ban on the vice president holding financial interests. Davao City Mayor Sebastian Duterte told the court the city awarded GenCorp Industries 19 catering contracts worth P34.49 million.

Court rulings

The court admitted bank, tax, corporate and property records in a 22-page order that Presiding Officer Francis Escudero issued on 5 November and announced on 6 November, the Philippine News Agency reported. The evidence includes Duterte's SALNs, Bureau of Internal Revenue documents, Anti-Money Laundering Council records, Securities and Exchange Commission records and financial records from nine banks. Land titles for Davao City and Samal properties, insurance and investment records, and firearms certifications for Duterte and Carpio were also admitted. The court excluded Commission on Audit disallowance records tied to the withdrawn confidential funds charge and rejected corporate records and forensic computations involving JTC Group of Companies Philippines Inc. and Pikimong Pikimong Philippines Corporation as unrelated to the remaining charge. Financial records from 2007 to 2021 may be used only to establish Duterte's position before she became vice president on 30 June 2022. Court spokesperson Reginald Tongol said admitting a document does not mean the court has ruled the prosecution's allegations or computations true. The court also restored a gag rule and barred online publication of protected bank, tax and personal records.

What happens next

Duterte has stayed away from the trial since it opened in July, apart from a brief appearance on the second day, when she said she was 'bloodied but unbowed', AsiaOne reported. She calls the proceedings political harassment and denies wrongdoing. The defense has listed 24 witnesses and plans to call accountants, bankers and corporate counsel for Duterte-linked firms, hoping to finish by year-end. Law professor Ralph Sarmiento declined an invitation to testify, saying he wanted to keep his independence as a constitutional law scholar, Davao Today reported. Corporate counsel Suzette Balucanag-Punay missed the 9 November hearing for a scheduled medical procedure. Defense spokesperson Michael Poa said on 9 November it was too early to say whether the vice president would take the stand, AsiaOne reported. Escudero said on 10 November he could not say when the trial would finish, but hoped it would be completed before Christmas or New Year, Inquirer reported.

Comments 0

Sources

14
  1. 01LIVE: Sara Duterte impeachment trial, Nov. 10EN
  2. 02LIVE UPDATES: Sara Duterte impeachment trial | Nov. 10, 2026EN
  3. 03Lawyers for Philippine VP Duterte open defence in high-stakes trialEN
  4. 04Lawyers for Philippine VP Duterte open defense in high-stakes trialEN
  5. 05Sara Duterte impeachment trial resumes with defense case on unexplained wealth chargeEN
  6. 06Sara Duterte's defense faces challenge as impeachment trial resumesEN
  7. 07LIVE: Impeachment trial of Sara Duterte, Nov. 9EN
  8. 08Impeachment court admits VP Sara financial records, restores gag ruleEN
  9. 09Impeachment trial begins for Philippine Vice President Sara DuterteEN
  10. 10Philippines launches VP Duterte impeachment trial amid political division - Al JazeeraEN
  11. 11Sara Duterte: Philippines house impeaches VP for a second time - BBCEN
  12. 12What to Expect from the Impeachment Trial of the Philippine Vice President Duterte - The Diplomat – Asia-Pacific Current Affairs MagazineEN
  13. 13Philippine presidential hopeful Sara Duterte impeached for second time - The GuardianEN
  14. 14Sarepta quits enrolling for confirmatory Phase 3 trial of ElevidysEN

All figures and quotations in this text come from the sources listed below.

Content prepared by the editorial team with AI assistance.

Dr. Amara Patel

Dr. Amara Patel

Economy, business and world

Dr. Amara Patel covers business, world affairs and the economy for FLASH24, working from filings, central bank statements and trade data rather than press releases, and she does not let company spin stand in for numbers. She checks revenue recognition, debt covenants and currency effects line by line against audited reports and regulatory disclosures. Her week includes calls with analysts, logistics operators and trade lawyers, and she watches the calendar for rate decisions, earnings dates and port and freight updates, comparing each against prior quarters. Outside the desk she tracks tech-company accounts and rides cargo bikes, which keeps her close to both the balance sheets she reads and the supply chains she covers. She does not publish a figure she cannot trace to a primary document.

Newsroom →

Comments

0
  1. No comments yet — be the first.

Write a comment

Comments are public. We do not publish abuse, spam or advertising.