Skip to content
World clockEU--:--UK--:--USA--:--CN--:--PLDEFRIT中文EN

portal about AI and technologyevents · analysis · interviews · technical background

Search
LIVE
›

Google, IBM and the Quantum Milestone That Keeps Moving

Google said its 53-qubit Sycamore processor sampled a quantum circuit in about 200 seconds. The company says a state-of-the-art supercomputer would need roughly 10,000 years for the same task. Six months earlier, IBM had claimed the first 50-qubit processor prototype.

TechnologyAnalysisGrace OkonkwoPublished: 28 September 20264 min readSources 6
Google, IBM and the Quantum Milestone That Keeps Moving

The word "milestone" has done a lot of work in quantum computing. Google's claim of quantum supremacy is the loudest one. It appeared in Nature's 150th anniversary issue in October 2019. It is not the only claim, and it does not end the argument.

The claim itself is narrow and specific. Google's own blog post says its Sycamore machine performed a test computation in 200 seconds. The best known algorithms on the most powerful supercomputers would need thousands of years to replicate it. Fortune reported the paper on 20 September 2019, and the researchers put a finer point on it. The processor took about 200 seconds to sample one instance of the quantum circuit a million times. A state-of-the-art supercomputer would need approximately 10,000 years for the equivalent task. The same paper estimated that running the experiment on a Google Cloud server would take 50 trillion hours.

Fortune obtained a copy of the paper after it appeared briefly on NASA.gov and was taken down. The Financial Times first reported the news. A Google spokesperson declined to confirm the paper's authenticity. A source at Google suggested NASA had published it early, before peer review. That process could take weeks or months.

Two years of claims, one disputed word

IBM got there first with a number, if not with the same word. On 10 November 2017, the Associated Press reported that IBM scientists had built and measured a processor prototype with 50 quantum bits. Dario Gil led IBM's quantum computing and artificial intelligence research division. He said it was the first time any company had built a quantum computer at that scale. Seth Lloyd is an MIT mechanical engineering professor not involved in the work. He said IBM likely still had glitches to work out. He called the announcement a sign of significant progress.

Google's own path to that scale ran through smaller chips. In April 2017, MIT Technology Review reported that John Martinis leads Google's quantum research group. He had given himself until the end of that year to reach quantum supremacy. The team had a nine-qubit chip arranged in a line. Its newest chip had six qubits in a two-by-three configuration. Martinis said he needed a grid of 49 qubits for the experiment. Designs for 30 to 50 qubits were already in progress.

By December 2017, Martinis was telling a conference at NASA Ames that qubit count was the wrong headline. "Press releases always talk about quantum space race in number of qubits," he said, according to Gizmodo. "It is about quantity, but also qubit quality." Google was then fabricating its 49 or 50 qubit device. Testing was to begin within two weeks.

The final machine was a 53-qubit processor called Sycamore. It was scaled back from a 72-qubit design named Bristlecone. Google's blog post framed the result as the "hello world" moment the field had been waiting for. It also conceded that it will be many years before anyone can implement a broader set of real-world applications.

What the milestone does not measure

IBM's Dario Gil told Fortune that the experiment was a highly special case laboratory experiment with no practical applications. He advised against using quantum supremacy as a progress metric. "The experiment and the 'supremacy' term will be misunderstood by nearly all," he said. "Quantum computers will never reign 'supreme' over classical computers, but will rather work in concert with them, since each have their unique strengths."

Jim Clarke is Intel Labs' director of quantum hardware. He called the update a notable mile marker. He said a commercially viable quantum computer would require many research and development advances first. "While development is still at mile one of this marathon, we strongly believe in the potential of this technology," he said.

That caution has a history. Chris Monroe is a University of Maryland professor and cofounder of the startup IonQ. He told MIT Technology Review in 2017 that supremacy would be "an academic milestone." "Afterward you still have to figure out how to make it more scalable and programmable," he said.

IBM's own metric work points the same way. At the American Physical Society March Meeting in 2019, IBM outlined a Quantum Volume of 16 for its 20-qubit Q System One. That was double the Quantum Volume of 8 for its then-current IBM Q system. Quantum Volume accounts for qubit count, connectivity and coherence time. It also covers gate and measurement errors, device cross talk and circuit software compiler efficiency. IBM said Quantum Volume would need to double every year to reach Quantum Advantage within the next decade. That is the point where quantum applications deliver significant advantages over classical computers. IBM has doubled the power of its quantum computers annually since 2017.

The Google paper's own conclusion is more ambitious than the experiment. The researchers predicted that quantum computing power will grow at a double exponential rate. That would outpace the exponential rate that defined Moore's Law. They also wrote: "We are only one creative algorithm away from valuable near-term applications."

That is the part still untested. The 200-second run is a data point. The 10,000-year comparison is a data point. Neither tells a company what to do on Monday.

Comments 0

Sources

6
  1. 01Google plans to reach a Quantum Computing milestone before the year is outEN
  2. 02IBM says it's reached milestone in quantum computingEN
  3. 03Why Google Is Poised to Hit the Next Critical Milestone in Quantum ComputingEN
  4. 04IBM hits quantum computing milestone, may see 'Quantum Advantage' in 2020sEN
  5. 05Google Claims 'Quantum Supremacy,' Marking a Major Milestone in ComputingEN
  6. 06What our quantum computing milestone meansEN

All figures and quotations in this text come from the sources listed below.

Content prepared by the editorial team with AI assistance.

Grace Okonkwo

Grace Okonkwo

AI, models and technology

Grace Okonkwo covers AI, models and technology for FLASH24, working from primary sources such as model cards, API documentation and benchmark papers rather than vendor summaries. She checks training data provenance, evaluation conditions and reported scores against the underlying datasets before any figure reaches print. She interviews researchers and engineers directly, tracks release calendars from major labs, and compares successive model versions on the same tests. Her own self-hosting, home-network and documentation-reading habits feed straight into that desk, since she tests tools on her own hardware first. She does not publish benchmark claims without a reproducible method.

Newsroom →

Comments

0
  1. No comments yet — be the first.

Write a comment

Comments are public. We do not publish abuse, spam or advertising.